On Social Media Advertising and #StopHateForProfit campaign

source: rappler.com


Many brands are joining the ‘Stop Hate for Profit’ campaign, against advertising on Facebook, until the social media platform does something substantial to stop the spread of hate speeches, racial abuse, and fake news. As of last count there were more than 1000 marketers who signed up for the boycott, including news-worthy brands like The North Face, Patagonia, Coca-Cola, Verizon, Starbucks, Microsoft, Unilever, Ford, etc. 
But, is there more to it apart from the hate speeches and racial abuses that brands are concerned about? 
Here are few of my thoughts:
  • Shooting the messenger syndrome
  • Perception Management
  • The (in)effectiveness of advertising on social media
Firstly, I think the issue is similar to proverbial, shooting the messenger. Facebook is not the content creator. It is the users. Facebook is only a platform where different people voice different opinions. Yes, some of these opinions are false, decisive, and dangerous.. but that is something got to do with the person who posted the content; Facebook is not at fault unless they wilfully promote or endorse such content.
If brands were really concerned about protecting their image… they should be even having checks and balances about who can use or consume their products. Also, brands work by exploiting people’s fears and aspirations. An insurance company typically works on fear, ‘What if something bad happens’; Or a sneaker company works by selling false hope riding on people’s aspiration of becoming some sort of a hero; Or a CPG company selling fairness/skin whitening cream by driving the fear, that if you are not fair enough, you’d be left behind.. Ok, on the last point, some brands are taking action…but hope you get the drift. 
The deep rooted fears, biases, and opinions of people has always been there even before social media. Facebook (or any social media platform) is just a medium for them to express it. Asking the social media platform to take action is like imposing your own biases over others.
Secondly, Branding works on perception. When a groundswell is happening that impacts the markets, brands cannot be seen a passive spectator. In this hyperconnected world, brands need to seen as ‘someone like us’, who are emotional, purposeful, and ‘doing-their-bit’ for social good. The idea of boycotting Facebook is more symbolic than anything else, since the brands cannot directly take on and alienate their consumers whose opinion resonates with the content that is termed hateful/abusive. If brands were serious about curing this malice then they would look at attacking the cause, not the symptoms.
With proper perception management, the word of mouth will spread amongst the woke folks on digital and some of them may even follow the brands on their social channels thus giving them positive mileage.
Thirdly, as brands pull back on marketing spends due to the impact of pandemic, they would look at stopping marketing tactics that has least impact on the brand. Many in the marketing world believe that the whole concept of digital advertising, especially, social media advertising, is hyped. To some extent this could be true.
Two popular ways the brands advertise their content on Facebook are as follows:
  1. Targeting the users basis there demographic/psychographic profile (ASL, hobbies, interests, etc)
  2. Re-targeting people who have visited their website (especially e-com) and reminding them to come back and complete their transactions
In the first instance, people will still get to know about the brand through other sources (offline and online) and other mediums of advertising, WOM, interest groups, forums, search, etc. In the second instance, many of them might anyway comeback to complete their transaction; with or without re-targeting ads.
Also social media advertising is contrary to the effective communications 101. We have learnt that in a communication framework there are 3 things, A sender, A medium, and A receiver. Social media is a place where the user is usually distracted, confused, emotional, etc.. basically, a place where lot of noise gets created. And if there is ‘noise’ in the medium then the communication gets distorted and is not effective. 
Communication works best when there is a pattern and not noise. Maybe that is why advertisers still have faith in print, television, and other digital publications (including google, ad networks, etc) to reach out to their audience

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Best Indian websites - 2007

Image
Hi, This was an article that appeared in PC World India Nice stuff Santosh ------------------------------------ Technology will dominate the future and the web is clearly one of its greatest manifestations. Forget the dotcom bust that many sceptics will remind you of The Web is going to become our way of life in India . There are enough statistics to point to the rapid growth of the Internet in India – number of connections, e-mail accounts, transaction revenue – all very convincing. But who needs statistics? Just a quick look around will reveal how web is fast replacing traditional brick-n-mortar operations. Be it picking new stocks or new friends, finding a job or a bride, there’s a web way to things that is proving far more effective, and rewarding. Websites today are built with robust understanding of users and available technology. They purposefully pursue fulfilling the needs of their audience but are grounded in strong business reality. And hence, unlike the fairy-tail era gone
Read more

10 Reasons Marketing Strategy should include the Internet

It may seem surprising but many companies, big and small, have yet to develop a rational Internet marketing strategy. Considering the Internet has now been used effectively by marketers since 1994, any organization without a strategy to utilize the Internet for marketing is probably making a big mistake. For any organization that still does not have a meaningful Internet marketing effort we offer 10 Reasons why you should. 1. The Go-To Place for Information Possibly the most important reason why companies need to have an active Internet marketing strategy is because of the transformation that has occurred in how customers seek information. While customers still visit stores, talk to sales representatives, look through magazines, and talk to friends to gather product information, an ever-increasing number of customers turn to the Internet as their primary knowledge source. In particular, they use search engines as their principle portal of knowledge as search sites have become the leadi
Read more

The Disappearance of Gully Cricket: A Reflection on Changing Times

Image
Gully cricket , once an integral part of Indian childhood, is now a fading memory. In the 80’s and early 90s, the streets were more than mere public spaces; they were stages for dreams. A bat, a ball, and a group of eager kids were all that was needed. Stumps were supported by stones, or stones themselves became stumps, or it could be a lamppost, or 3 lines drawn with a piece of brick on a compound wall. If nothing, it would be two hawai chappals that acts as wickets. A twig could be a stand-in for a second bat, and everyone played with a shared spirit. The road in front of anyone's house was open to all—a place where games, conversations, and sometimes even family functions spilled over. The essence of gully cricket was its simplicity and collectiveness. No one really owned anything individually. If one kid had a bat, it became everyone’s bat. The game was not defined by boundaries of ownership or the idea of personal space. Rather, it thrived on the joy of shared resources and ex
Read more